What are public punishments for judges for? | behind the scenes of arbitration

Another referee and VAR publicly punished. Luiz Flavio de Oliveira and Wagner Reway have carried out effectively beneath their capabilities and actually need a while on the ‘alternative bench’. But what are public punishments for? What is the level of this?

It is vital for groups to indicate power and fulfill their followers. For followers, punishment for referees who’ve made a mistake towards their group is at all times deserved. He brings hours of debates on sports activities packages to the press. And for the judging panel?

That’s the query I ask myself each time I see a referee publicly chastised for errors. I instantly draw an analogy with the coach of a group who seems at a press convention and says that his participant is out of the group as a result of he missed a penalty to win the recreation. Or the official document on social media that informs that the athlete who missed the penalty may have a dialog with a psychologist, nutritionist and coach and watch ten movies of collections to learn to do that earlier than he can return to play. .I shortly notice how absurd this might be for the gamers, however for the referees it’s a actuality.

Luiz Flávio de Oliveira was despatched off after Flamengo x Athletico — Photo: Cesar Greco / Ag Palmeiras

The present referee administration is made up of respectable and technical individuals, but it surely misplaced its energy the day it determined to publicly punish a referee attributable to a membership criticism. This path, which normally results in an abyss of no return, is opposite to the present and media needs of the golf equipment, however threatens the credibility of the Commission’s work.

See the VAR evaluation for the bid involving Gabigol and Fernandinho

Judges are not assured as a result of they reside with the specter of public punishment, however as a result of they know they are not linear and rational. The first referee to be publicly punished was Bruno Arleu for lacking a penalty on Pikachu of Fortaleza towards Goiás after seeing the recreation on a monitor.

But earlier than and after that transfer, there have been different extra critical errors that did not deserve public punishment from the umpire’s fee. Wagner Magalhães did not rule out Cuiaba’s Rivas for a really onerous deal with on Athletico’s Erick, even after watching the supply on the monitor.

See VAR analysis for Léa Pereira's potential penalty in Flamengo 0 x 0 Athletico-PR

See VAR evaluation for Léa Pereira’s potential penalty in Flamengo 0 x 0 Athletico-PR

Raphael Claus was additionally known as by VAR and Botafogo’s Del Piage failed to attain a transparent penalty on Atlético-MG’s Ademir. Wilton Sampaio had VAR rule out a professional objective by Fortaleza towards Palmeiras, which was performed utterly accidentally by Matheus Vargas.

Anyway, the listing is big. In the first spherical alone, 18 apparent fouls have been recorded, which weren’t corrected regardless of VAR.

I’ve at all times been towards this exposé, as a result of each the punishment and the lack of standards in it weaken the belief of the competent judges and the credibility of the fee in entrance of the golf equipment. And a coach who “loses the locker room” would not win a championship.

See VAR analysis for Arrascaeta's possible sending-off in Flamengo 0 x 0 Athletico-PR

See VAR evaluation for Arrascaeta’s attainable sending-off in Flamengo 0 x 0 Athletico-PR

Unfortunately, this path was chosen, and arbitrage and expertise administration at this level gave approach to disaster and threat. This occurred attributable to the Commission’s personal selections and the lack of a transparent technique on the right way to cope with the troublesome state of affairs that at all times existed between the arbitration and the golf equipment.

This state of affairs won’t enhance with the assembly at the CBF, the place each side took the alternative to precise their displeasure with the arbitration. The turning level talked about by the president of the refereeing fee, Wilson Seneme, this assembly won’t ever occur. A standard technique needs to be outlined to advertise cultural change in Brazilian soccer. Without this, no vital change will likely be efficient. On the opposite, this hostile surroundings will worsen in the coming months with mounting strain on the officiating as the championship attracts to an in depth.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.